Přehled
Rozhodnutí
FIFTH SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 2614/04
Iryna Vlasivna NAKALYUZHNA against Ukraine
and 71 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 3 December 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Boštjan M. Zupančič, President,
Ann Power-Forde,
Helena Jäderblom, judges,
and Stephen Phillips, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates stated in the annexed table,
Having regard to the decision to apply the pilot-judgment procedure taken in the case of Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine, no. 40450/04, 15 October 2009,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
The applicants are Ukrainian nationals, except for the applicants in applications nos. 17631/07 and 50344/07, who are respectively Moldovan and Russian nationals. Applicants in the applications nos. 17516/04 and 8062/09 are legal entities registered in Ukraine. Personal details of all the applicants are set out in the annexed table.
The Ukrainian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr Nazar Kulchytskyy, of the Ministry of Justice.
The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.
On the dates set out in the annexed table below the national courts held for the applicants and ordered the defendants under these judgments (debtors) to take certain measures or to pay various amounts to the applicants. The judgments became binding but the authorities delayed their enforcement.
The applications were communicated to the Ukrainian Government within the pilot judgment in the case of Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov cited above.
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained principally about the lengthy non‑enforcement of judgments in their favour.
THE LAW
The Court first considers that in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications listed in in the appended table should be joined, given their common legal background.
The respondent Government informed the Court that the applications did not comply with the admissibility criteria of the Convention and thus invited the Court to declare them inadmissible.
The applicants disagreed.
The Court has carefully examined the applications and notes that in each case the communicated non-enforcement complaints are inadmissible on the grounds set out in the annexed table (see last column).
The Court further notes that, in the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matter complained of is within its competence, all the other complaints of the applicants do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that all the applications listed in the annexed table are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 1, 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Stephen Phillips Boštjan M. Zupančič
Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
No. | Application no. and date of introduction | Applicant name date of birth place of residence | Relevant domestic decision | Reasons for inadmissibility |
2614/04 01/12/2003 | Iryna Vlasivna NAKALYUZHNA 14/02/1976 Bobryk | 1) Brovary Court, 29/03/1999 2) Brovary Court, 02/10/2003 | Non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
16569/04 30/03/2004 | Aleksandr Viktorovich VOYTENKO | 1) Oleksandriya Court, 02/04/2002 2) Oleksandriy Court, 26/01/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
16981/04 04/03/2004 | Leonid Semenovych VOROTNIKOV 08/07/1940 Zidky | Zmiyivskyy District Court of Kharkiv Region, 20/04/2001 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
17516/04 15/03/2004 | OPTIMA, TOV Kyiv | Kyiv Commercial Court of Appeal, 26/11/2001, as amended by the Higher Commercial Court on 25/01/2002 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
38825/04 02/12/2003 | Olga Mikhaylovna DYAKOVA 03/02/1957 Donetsk | Budennovskyy District Court of Donetsk, 13/03/1997 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
17533/05 27/04/2005 | Zoya Fedorovna NEKHOROSHKOVA | Zhovtnevyy District Court of Dnipropetrovsk, 19/04/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
29637/05 22/07/2005 | Andrey Nikolayevich KOZLOV 01/08/1966 Sevastopol | 1) Navy Court of Appeal, 14/04/2005 2) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 26/09/2006 3) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 13/12/2006 4) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 08/10/2007 | 1) Six months 2) No significant disadvantage 3) No significant disadvantage 4) No significant disadvantage | |
264/06 07/12/2005 | Vasyl Dmytrovych KRAVCHENKO 11/11/1947 Kyiv | Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 13/08/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
1787/06 23/12/2005 | Lyudmyla Adamivna KOVNER Chernigiv | 1) Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 28/03/2002 2) Novozavodskyy DIstrict Court of Chernigiv, 27/01/2005 3) Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 27/10/2005 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) No significant disadvantage 3) No significant disadvantage | |
3264/06 15/12/2005 | Vasyl Semenovych SHCHERBAK Kyiv | Shevchenkivskyy District Court of Kyiv, 28/07/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
10408/06 03/03/2006 | Andrey Nikolayevich GAMOV Zaporozhye | 1) Lugansk Commercial Court, 01/11/2000 2) Donetsk Commercial Court, 14/03/2002 3) Donetsk Commercial Court, 22/02/2006 4) Lugansk Commercial Court, 14/06/2006 5) Donetsk Commercial Court, 15/02/2007 | Ratione personae | |
10706/06 06/03/2006 | Yuriy Nikolayevich BOGDANCHENKO Sevastopol | 1) Sevastopol City Court of Appeal, 20/11/2001 2) Sevastopol City Court of Appeal, 03/02/2005 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) No significant disadvantage | |
10846/06 31/01/2006 | Volodymyr Fedorovych KOVNER Chernigiv | 1) Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 28/03/2002 2) Novozavodskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 02/03/2004 3) Desnyanskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 11/08/2005, as amended by the judgment of 19/10/2005 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 3) No significant disadvantage | |
23289/06 19/05/2006 | Andrey Nikolayevich KOZLOV 01/08/1966 Sevastopol | 1) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 16/02/2006 2) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 20/03/2007 | 1) No significant disadvantage 2) Manifestly ill-founded | |
31667/06 18/07/2006 | Leonid Vasilyevich MOSKALENKO 14/07/1952 Donetsk | 1) Tsentralno-Miskyy District Court of Gorlivka, 10/02/1995 2) Kalininskyy District Court of Donetsk, 07/10/2004 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
32137/06 03/07/2006 | Mykhaylo Mykhaylovych DOVBENCHUK 25/11/1945 Kalush | 1) Kalush Court, 05/02/2002 2) Kalush Court, 08/10/2003 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
32932/06 07/07/2006 | Feofan Antonovich NAZAREVICH 27/04/1939 Lutsk | Lutsk Court, 29/01/2002 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
41754/06 02/10/2006 | Vladyslava Oleksiyivna MINAYEVA 14/08/1974 Kyiv | 1) Svyatoshynskyy District Curt of Kyiv, 24/05/2005 2) Kyiv City Court of Appeal, 26/06/2006 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) No significant disadvantage | |
42204/06 09/10/2006 | Galina Viktorovna ITSENKO 16/08/1963 Mykolayiv | 1) Zavovskyy District Court of Mykolayiv, 22/07/2003 2) Zavovskyy District Court of Mykolayiv, 19/03/2004 3) Zavovskyy District Court of Mykolayiv, 13/12/2004 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
43178/06 06/10/2006 | Tamara Nikolayevna TUOVINEN Riistavesi | Leninskyy District Court of Kharkiv, 20/02/2002 | No significant disadvantage | |
46410/06 03/09/2006 | Oleksandr Mykolayovych VOLKOV 12/10/1954 Ivano-Frankivsk | 1) Ivano-Frankivsk Court, 25/03/2002 2) Ivano-Frankivsk Court, 06/10/2005, as amended by the Higher Administrative Court, 06/12/2006 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
284/07 02/12/2006 | Valeriy Arkadyevich PARKHOMCHUK Dneprodzerzhinsk | Dnipropetrovsk Regional Commercial Court, 22/11/2001 | Six months | |
4135/07 11/10/2006 | Stanislav Aleksandrovich BONDARENKO Donetsk | Yenakiyevo Court, 05/06/2000 | Six months | |
9772/07 31/01/2007 | Aleksandr Alekseyevich YEGOROV 10/07/1957 Donetsk | Kyivskyy District Court of Donetsk, 02/06/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
15160/07 30/03/2007 | Oleksandr Fedorovych PANCHENKO 31/08/1958 Molodogvardeysk | Krasnyy Luch Court, 02/06/2003 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
17631/07 02/04/2007 | Ilya Alekseyevich VIDRASHKO Bender Moldovan | Odesa Regional Court of Appeal, 11/09/2003 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
33996/07 26/07/2007 | Vladimir Fedorovich URSOL Pervomaysk | Lugansk Regional Commercial Court, 30/05/2005 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
39228/07 16/07/2007 | Yuriy Ivanovich POLOZHIY Kramatorsk | Kramatorsk Court, 08/08/2003 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
40718/07 18/08/2007 | Vasiliy Aleksandrovich KOVALYOV Konstantinovka | Kostyantynivka Court, 16/12/2004 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
41114/07 21/08/2007 | Anatoliy Mikhaylovich SERBIN 24/07/1938 Illichevsk | Odesa Regional Court of Appeal, 19/12/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
44311/07 29/09/2007 | Lidiya Nikolayevna MITYUSHINA Oleksandrivka | Oleksandriya Court, 04/03/1998 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
45543/07 03/10/2007 | Mariya Stanislavovna POKOTYLO Bilenke | 1) Dobropillya Court, 24/09/1996 2) Dobropillya Court, 08/04/2002 3) Dobropillya Court, 08/09/2005 as amended by the Donetsk Regional Court of Appeal on 24/11/2005 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 3) No significant disadvantage | |
47078/07 15/10/2007 | Aleksandr Iosifovich RUBAKHA 25/07/1950 Dnipropetrovsk | Zhovtnevyy District Court of Dnipropetrovsk, 06/10/2004 | No significant disadvantage | |
50344/07 30/10/2007 | Vladimir Yakubovich AKHMETOV 1960 Shandrygolovo | Slovyansk Court, 27/04/2006 | No significant disadvantage | |
51778/07 01/11/2007 | Vyacheslav Ivanovych ANADSKYY Yenakiyeve | Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 25/06/2007 | No significant disadvantage No longer a victim | |
2317/08 15/12/2007 | Georgiy Ivanovych BOBAL 27/01/1945 Svalyava | 1) Svalyavskyy District Court of Zakarpattya Region, 28/03/2005 2) Svalyavskyy District Court of Zakarpattya Region, 09/03/2000 3) Svalyavskyy District Court of Zakarpattya Region, 01/12/2000 4) Svalyavskyy District Court of Zakarpattya Region, 06/12/2001 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
6962/08 18/01/2008 | Vladyslav Volodymyrovych LYSYANYY 14/06/1965 Kyiv | Kyiv City Court of Appeal, 21/02/2005 | No significant disadvantage | |
7192/08 26/01/2008 | Oleksandr Borysovych KHOMENKO Kaniv | Kaniv Court, 06/02/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
7792/08 28/01/2008 | Alla Ivanivna POSUNKO 27/12/1949 Gorlivka | Mykytivskyy District Court of Gorlivka, 30/10/2000 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
7806/08 30/01/2008 | Volodymyr Leonidovych DUDIN 30/11/1952 Trostyanets | Vinnytsya Circuit Administrative Court, 20/12/2007 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
8186/08 07/02/2008 | Oleg Ivanovych GELYK 12/05/1947 Kyiv | Solomyanskyy District Court of Kyiv, 27/12/2005 | Ratione personae | |
9150/08 30/01/2008 | Vadym Ivanovych TARNAVSKYY 17/08/1941 Odesa | Prymorskyy District Court of Odesa, 25/12/2000 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
14854/08 12/03/2008 | Igor Anatoliyovych LIPANOV 22/07/1962 Zhytomyr | Korolyovskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 17/10/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
17382/08 26/03/2008 | Kateryna Mykolayivna YEFREMOVA 22/04/1954 Bilogirsk | Belogorsk Court, 15/03/2005, as amended by the Crimea Court of Appeal on 11/07/2005 | Six months | |
21955/08 16/04/2008 | Oleksandr Leonidovych KRYCHYLSKYY 08/02/1982 Kostopil | 1) Rivnenskyy District Court of Rivne Region, 13/06/2002 2) Kostopil Court, 25/07/2003 3) Kostopil Court, 28/12/2006 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
23110/08 29/04/2008 | Aleksandr Lazarevich DRONOV Rovenky | Rovenky Court, 20/12/2004 | Six months | |
23460/08 08/05/2008 | Volodymyr Viktorovych KOROTUN Melitopol | Melitopol Court, 19/09/2006 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
23471/08 05/05/2008 | Anatoliy Vasilyevich MATVIYENKO 04/11/1941 Kherson | 1) Komsomolsk Court, 09/09/1997 2) Komsomolsk Court, 25/05/2000 3) Komsomolsk Court, 03/12/2004 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
33553/08 04/06/2008 | Borys Mykytovych BEZKOROVAYNYY 08/12/1956 Korop | 1) Korop Court, 21/02/2006 2) Bakhmach Court, 23/01/2007 3) Bakhmach Court, 23/02/2007 4) Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 29/03/2007 | No significant disadvantage | |
36619/08 16/07/2008 | Olga Oleksandrivna PERGAT 05/08/1973 Beryslav | Beryslav Court, 26/06/2007, as amended by the Kherson Regional Court of Appeal on 13/11/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
44410/08 08/09/2008 | Mykola Vasylovych TKACHOV 12/09/1976 Oleksandriya | Court order of the Oleksandriya Court, 30/08/2007 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
48913/08 16/06/2008 | Petr Mikhaylovich KORZHIKOV 12/07/1947 Chernigiv | Desnyanskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 28/09/2005 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
50601/08 09/10/2008 | Nataliya Mykolayivna UKRAYINTSEVA 23/02/1966 Kirovograd | Kirovograd Regional Court of Appeal, 03/12/2003 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
89/09 20/06/2008 | Tamara Semenivna RUDYK Chernigiv | Desnyanskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 24/10/2007 | No significant disadvantage | |
823/09 09/12/2008 | Denis Denisovich GUMANYUK Odesa | Suvorovskyy District Court of Odesa, 27/09/2000 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
2537/09 19/12/2008 | Lyubov Petrivna BONDAREVA 21/08/1955 Velyka-Pysarivka | Prymorskyy District Court of Odesa, 30/07/2004 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
8062/09 27/01/2009 | ZAVOD ZBVIK, VAT Makiyivka | Dnipropetrovsk Commercial Court of Appeal, 24/12/2003 | Six months | |
39156/09 09/07/2009 | Antonina Yosyfivna GORDEYUK 02/10/1934 Lviv | Shevchenkivskyy District Court of Lviv, 29/07/2008 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
46466/09 13/08/2009 | Mykola Vasylyovych GOMOLYAKO Nizhyn | Nizhyn Court, 14/07/2005 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
49347/09 03/09/2009 | Vasyl Vasylyovych BARSUCHENKO 24/04/1946 Kyiv | Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv 28/09/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
49563/09 03/09/2009 | Leonid Vasylyovych PIDCHYBIY 02/05/1967 Kyiv | Dniprovskyy District Court of Kyiv, 05/12/2005 | No significant disadvantage | |
56702/09 09/10/2009 | Andrey Anatolyevich KOLOMIYCHUK 10/03/1972 Razdolnoye | 1) Rozdolne District Court of Crimea, 02/04/2008 2) Rozdolne District Court of Crimea, 21/09/2006 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) No significant disadvantage | |
13161/10 20/02/2010 | Sergey Gennadiyevich NEFEDOV 11/04/1959 Zhovtneve | Kalininskyy District Court of Donetsk, 30/03/2007 | No significant disadvantage | |
20036/10 17/03/2010 | Oleksandr Grygorovych KOLISNYK 15/05/1957 Kremenchuk | Poltava Circuit Administrative Court, 21/04/2009 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
20919/10 29/03/2010 | Nataliya Protazovna GERTOVA 12/06/1954 Mykolayiv | 1) Zavodskyy DIstrict Court of Myklayiv, 15/10/2003 2) Zavodskyy DIstrict Court of Myklayiv, 03/12/2004 | Six months | |
24717/10 23/04/2010 | Valeriy Mykolayovych VOLOSHYN 20/04/1953 Lugansk | Artemivskyy District Court of Lugansk, 16/10/2008 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
36760/10 18/06/2010 | Sergiy Dmytrovych AKULOV 03/04/1962 Cherkasy | Mankivka Court, 03/12/2009 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
61710/10 12/10/2010 | Galina Danilovna PANCHIK 17/01/1939 Sevastopol Mikhail Vasilyevich PANCHIK 14/10/1973 Sevastopol | 1) Nakhimovskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 12/08/1998 2) Nakhimovskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 30/07/1999 3) Nakhimovskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 30/07/2003 | 1) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 2) Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies 3) No significant disadvantage | |
63416/10 15/10/2010 | Nikolay Trofimovich TRETYAK Alushta | Alushta Court, 06/09/2007 | Manifestly ill-founded | |
63844/10 21/10/2010 | Andrey Yevgenyevich MIKHEYEV 24/12/1963 Molodizhne | Zaliznychnyy District Court of Simferopol, 14/02/2008 | Ratione personae | |
2343/11 19/11/2010 | Svetlana Borisovna ALBUL 07/10/1969 Yevpatoriya | Court of Appeal of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 12/12/2005 | Ratione personae and non-exhaustion of domestic remedies | |
5043/11 12/01/2011 | Anatoliy Andriyovych FILIPOVYCH Kyiv | Kyiv Circuit Administrative Court, 29/09/2008 | No significant disadvantage |