ILIĆ A OSTATNÍ proti Srbsku

Přehled

Text rozhodnutí

Datum rozhodnutí

17.12.2013

Rozhodovací formace

výbor

Významnost

Číslo stížnosti / sp. zn.

27622/12

Rozhodnutí

SECOND SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 27622/12
Miroslav ILIĆ against Serbia
and 99 other applications
(see list appended)

The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 17 December 2013 as a Committee composed of:

Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque, President,

Dragoljub Popović,

Helen Keller, judges,

and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar.

Having regard to the above applications lodged on 12 September 2011,

Having regard to the formal declarations accepting a friendly settlement of the cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They are all Serbian nationals and were represented by Mr M. Moskovljević, a lawyer practising in Kruševac.

The Serbian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr S. Carić.

All applicants are former employees of the same socially-owned company - Građevinsko preduzeće Jastrebac - from Kruševac (hereinafter: the debtor). In the course of insolvency proceedings against the debtor on 11 July 2003 the Kraljevo Commercial Court adopted decisions (domestic case no. S St.2505/02) according to which the debtor was ordered to pay the applicants certain sums. The applicants complained about the respondent State’s failure to enforce the said decisions rendered in their favour.

After unsuccessful friendly settlement negotiations, by letter dated 9 September 2013 the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a declaration with a view to resolving the issues raised by the application.

The declaration provided as follows:

“I declare that the Government of the Republic of Serbia is ready to accept that there had been a violation of the applicants’ right under Article 6 paragraph 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention.

I further declare that within three-month period the Government offer to pay to the applicants listed below, the sums awarded in the domestic decisions under consideration in this case, less any amounts which may have already been paid on the basis of the said decisions.

These sums shall be payable within three months from the date of delivery of the decision of the Court.

This payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.

The Government regret the occurrence of the actions which have led to the bringing of the present applications.”

On 15 October 2013, the Court received a letter from the applicants’ representative informing the Court that they had agreed to the terms of the Government’s declaration.

THE LAW

The Court considers that, in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal background.

The Court finds that following the applicants’ express agreement to the terms of the declaration made by the Government the case should be treated as a friendly settlement between the parties.

The Court takes note of the friendly settlement reached between the parties. It is satisfied that the settlement is based on respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols and finds no reasons to justify a continued examination of the applications. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the case out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court unanimously

Decides to join the applications;

Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 39 of the Convention.

Stanley Naismith Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque
Registrar President

Appendix

No	Application No	Applicant Date of birth Place of residence	Represented by
	27622/12	Miroslav ILIĆ 20/11/1957 selo Đunis	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27626/12	Miroslav RADOVANOVIĆ 17/08/1951 selo Toljevac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27633/12	Boban JABLIĆ 31/08/1972 selo G. Koševi	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27637/12	Velimir KOVAČ 27/08/1956 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27643/12	Milija JAKOVLJEVIĆ 19/10/1950 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27647/12	Radmila STOJANOVIĆ 14/03/1955 selo Mudrakovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27659/12	Vladislav JOVANOVIĆ 03/02/1940 selo Crkvina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27663/12	Miroslava BRADAŠ 09/10/1947 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27665/12	Rade MILOŠEVIĆ 31/01/1967 selo Đunis	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27666/12	Zlata MILUNOVIĆ 07/01/1959 selo G. Stepoš	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27670/12	Mica MILENKOVIĆ 20/09/1957 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27685/12	Radomir MILENKOVIĆ 06/10/1950 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27690/12	Slavoljub MILENKOVIĆ 30/08/1946 selo Kobilje	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27692/12	Dobrica MILETIĆ 12/08/1958 selo Sušica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27695/12	Dragomir KOVAČEVIĆ 20/02/1942 selo Dedina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27697/12	Borivoje JOVANOVIĆ 19/10/1941 selo Meševo	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27698/12	Vojkan KRSTIĆ 11/03/1972 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27701/12	Slavoljub TOMIĆ 14/06/1971 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27702/12	Radomir LAZAREVIĆ 05/12/1953 selo Dedina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27705/12	Zoran TOŠIĆ 22/02/1966 selo Dedina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27708/12	Božur MARKOVIĆ 13/09/1951 selo Šogolj	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27712/12	Slobodan CVETKOVIĆ 10/10/1943 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27715/12	Milosija VELJKOVIĆ 22/09/1955 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27723/12	Vojislav STOJANOVIĆ 17/01/1937 selo Dedina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27724/12	Nenad MARKOVIĆ 08/04/1973 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27728/12	Goran MATIĆ 11/01/1964 selo Vratare	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27729/12	Zoran CVETKOVIĆ 25/12/1972 selo Mačkovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27731/12	Dragan CVETKOVIĆ 22/12/1948 selo Mačkovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27733/12	Zoran MILENKOVIĆ 20/07/1956 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27741/12	Dragan STEPANOVIĆ 30/04/1943 selo V. Lomnica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27742/12	Sladan STOJAKOVIĆ 03/02/1973 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27746/12	Nevenka STOJANOVIĆ 04/12/1946 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27748/12	Zoran MARIĆ 24/08/1954 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27751/12	Bogomir MILANOVIĆ 02/01/1955 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27753/12	Dušan RADOSAVLJEVIĆ 07/06/1946 selo V.kupci	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27755/12	Dejan KOSTIĆ 18/10/1967 selo Makresane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27757/12	Milomir MIHAJLOVIĆ 02/01/1947 selo Lipovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27769/12	Milorad RAKIĆ 16/10/1949 selo Bošnjane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27777/12	Nebojša RAKIĆ 05/05/1958 selo Bošnjane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27778/12	Dragica KOSTIĆ 28/06/1952 selo Dedina	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27783/12	Milorad MILENKOVIĆ 01/10/1949 selo Doljane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27784/12	Slavica RAKIĆ 27/06/1963 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27786/12	Milorad MILENKOVIĆ 17/12/1946 selo V.lomnica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27788/12	Milovan RADOVANOVIĆ 03/05/1953 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27791/12	Živorad KOSTIĆ 30/03/1947 selo G.stepos	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27796/12	Slobodanka MILETIĆ 18/04/1953 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27799/12	Mirjana MILETIĆ 25/04/1948 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27803/12	Zoran MILETIĆ 14/12/1955 selo Stalac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27809/12	Slavoljub MILADINOVIĆ 01/01/1955 selo Kukljin	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27829/12	Miodrag STOJMIROVIĆ 08/06/1943 Parunovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27833/12	Dragoš ĆALOVIĆ 08/07/1950 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27837/12	Vujadin ŠĆEKIĆ 01/05/1965 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27845/12	Zoran GRČAK 16/03/1971 selo Lipovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27850/12	Branislav DIŠLJENKOVIĆ 04/10/1957 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27851/12	Jovan MILENKOVIĆ 12/04/1948 selo V.lomnica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27853/12	Miroslav STOJANOVIĆ 03/05/1941 selo Grevci	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27857/12	Slavica ANTIĆ 10/09/1967 Grad Stalać	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27860/12	Strahinja STANOJEVIĆ 17/04/1965 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27862/12	Olgica STEVANOVIĆ 10/03/1974 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27947/12	Peka ĐOKIĆ 20/08/1966 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	27992/12	Dragan PRŠIĆ 10/02/1952 selo Trbotin	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28029/12	Rade TOMIĆ 27/09/1958 selo Zlatari	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28045/12	Vojislav STOJANOVIĆ 21/08/1948 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28050/12	Saša STOJANOVIĆ 22/01/1974 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28056/12	Zorica STANIĆ 29/04/1951 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28079/12	Slavica STANKOVIĆ 15/11/1950 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28099/12	Zoran RAKIĆ 15/03/1967 selo Bošnjane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28104/12	Branislav BATOČANIN 19/07/1955 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28112/12	Zagorka VALJAREVIĆ 04/10/1946 selo Kobilje	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28119/12	Ljubodrag DAVIDOVIĆ 04/09/1952 selo Šanac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28125/12	Dragica ĐUKIĆ 19/07/1964 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28133/12	Đorđe MILIĆ 19/01/1946 selo Pepeljevac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28139/12	Radojica RADOJKOVIĆ 03/04/1948 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28171/12	Stojanka NIKOLIĆ 23/02/1963 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28200/12	Milija PAVLOVIĆ 05/04/1955 selo Dvorane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28208/12	Milovanka MILUNOVIĆ 05/01/1956 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28215/12	Milan PAVLOVIĆ 30/06/1949 selo Žiljci	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28218/12	Živomir PAVLOVIĆ 22/04/1951 selo V.kruševica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28223/12	Milosav PAVLIČEVIĆ 07/07/1953 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28227/12	Grujica CVETKOVIĆ 11/05/1959 selo Mačkovac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28251/12	Saša RADMANOVAC 10/06/1974 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28271/12	Zoran NIKOLIĆ 14/03/1977 selo G.stepoš	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28275/12	Slađana RADIVOJEVIĆ 28/08/1961 Prizren	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28282/12	Radoslavka MILANOVIĆ 15/11/1952 selo Gari	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28298/12	Radoslav STOJADINOVIĆ 22/12/1948 selo Zdravinje	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28325/12	Ivan LUKIĆ 16/10/1977 selo M.Vrbnica	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28348/12	Živojin RADOJEVIĆ 09/10/1943 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28356/12	Radiša SAVIĆ 01/03/1954 selo Majdevo	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28357/12	Dimitrije LUKIĆ 08/11/1947 selo Doljane	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28360/12	Radule SAULOVIĆ 03/03/1940 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28363/12	Živko KOSTIĆ 11/06/1944 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28366/12	Vujadin SPASOJEVIĆ 07/08/1957 selo Štitare	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28371/12	Života STAMENKOVIĆ 25/06/1956 selo Vukanja	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28375/12	Radica RADOJKOVIĆ 04/01/1956 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28377/12	Živorad ANĐELKOVIĆ 14/08/1947 selo Gaglovo	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28382/12	Slađan STANOJLOVIĆ 03/12/1948 selo Boljevac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28425/12	Goce STANOJEVIĆ 09/01/1959 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28429/12	Dragiša STEVIĆ 18/03/1940 Grad Stalac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28434/12	Aleksandar SIJIĆ 22/04/1969 selo G.Zleginje	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ
	28438/12	Anica RATKOVIĆ 11/07/1944 Kruševac	Milorad MOSKOVLJEVIĆ