DUYMAZ A OSTATNÍ proti Turecku

Přehled

Text rozhodnutí

Datum rozhodnutí

25.6.2024

Rozhodovací formace

výbor

Významnost

Číslo stížnosti / sp. zn.

58437/17

Rozsudek

SECOND SECTION

CASE OF DUYMAZ AND OTHERS v. TÜRKİYE

(Applications nos. 58437/17 and 313 others)

JUDGMENT

STRASBOURG

25 June 2024

This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision.

In the case of Duymaz and Others v. Türkiye,

The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:

Pauliine Koskelo, President,
Lorraine Schembri Orland,
Frédéric Krenc, judges,
and Dorothee von Arnim, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to:

the applications against the Republic of Türkiye lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by the applicants listed in the appended table (“the applicants”), on the various dates indicated therein;

the decision to give notice of the complaints under Article 5 of the Convention concerning the alleged lack of reasonable suspicion regarding the commission of an offence, the alleged lack of relevant and sufficient reasons when ordering and extending the pre-trial detention, the length of pre-trial detention, the ineffectiveness of the judicial review of the lawfulness of detention and the absence of a remedy to obtain compensation to the Turkish Government (“the Government”), represented by their Agent, Mr Hacı Ali Açıkgül, Head of the Department of Human Rights of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Türkiye, and to declare inadmissible the remainder of the applications;

the parties’ observations;

the decision to reject the Government’s objection to the examination of the applications by a Committee;

Having deliberated in private on 4 June 2024,

Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

1. The present applications mainly concern the arrest and pre-trial detention of the applicants in the aftermath of the coup attempt of 15 July 2016, on suspicion of their membership of an organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation / Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “FETÖ/PDY”), which was considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt (for further background information see Akgün v. Turkey, no. 19699/18, §§ 3-9 and §§ 106-07, 20 July 2021).

2. On various dates, the applicants were arrested and placed in pre-trial detention, mainly on suspicion of membership of the FETÖ/PDY, an offence punishable under Article 314 of the Criminal Code (see Baş v. Turkey, no. 66448/17, § 58, 3 March 2020). The detention orders relied principally on the nature of the alleged offence, the state of the evidence and the potential sentence. It was also noted that investigations into the coup attempt were being conducted across the country, that statements had not yet been taken from all the suspects and that the alleged offence was among the “catalogue” offences listed in Article 100 § 3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CCP) (for the text of Article 100 of the CCP, as relevant, see Baş, cited above, § 61). It appears from the initial detention orders and the documents available in the case files that the majority of the applicants were identified as users of the ByLock messaging system. Moreover, some of the applicants were suspected of being affiliated with the FETÖ/PDY based on witness statements, or of financing the FETÖ/PDY in view of their use of accounts in Bank Asya – a bank allegedly linked to FETÖ/PDY –, possession of pro-FETÖ/PDY publications and/or United States one-dollar bills with an “F” serial number (denoting the initial of the forename “Fetullah”), and/or their employment by and/or memberships in FETÖ/PDY-affiliated institutions and organisations. The challenges brought by the applicants against their detention, including by reason of the alleged lack of reasonable suspicion of having committed the offence imputed to them, were dismissed, including by the Constitutional Court.

3. According to the latest information provided by the parties, most of the applicants were convicted of membership of a terrorist organisation by the first instance courts. It appears that, in some of the applications, the criminal proceedings are still pending before appeal courts or the Constitutional Court.

THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT

JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS

4. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single judgment.

ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 5 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION

5. The applicants complained that there had been no specific evidence giving rise to a reasonable suspicion, within the meaning of Article 5 § 1 (c) of the Convention, that they had committed a criminal offence necessitating pre-trial detention.

6. The Government urged the Court to declare this complaint inadmissible in respect of the applicants who had not made use of the compensatory remedy under Article 141 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, or whose compensation claims were still pending. They further asked the Court to declare the applications inadmissible for abuse of the right of application to the extent that the applicants had not informed the Court of the developments in their cases following the lodging of their applications.

7. The Court notes that similar objections have already been dismissed in other cases against Türkiye (see, for instance, Baş v. Turkey, no. 66448/17, §§ 118-21, 3 March 2020, and Turan and Others v. Turkey, nos. 75805/16 and 426 others, §§ 57-64, 23 November 2021), and sees no reason to depart from those findings in the present case. The Court therefore considers that this complaint is not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention or inadmissible on any other grounds. It must therefore be declared admissible.

8. The Court notes that, when ordering the applicants’ initial pre-trial detention, the magistrate’s courts sought to justify their decisions by making a general reference to Article 100 of the CCP and the potential sentence, as well as to “the evidence in the file”. However, in doing so, they simply cited the wording of the provision in question, without actually specifying what the evidence in question entailed and why it constituted a reasonable suspicion that the applicant had committed the offence in question. The Court refers in this connection to its findings in the judgment of Baş (cited above, §§ 190‑195), according to which the vague and general references to the wording of Article 100 of the CCP and to the evidence in the file cannot be regarded as sufficient to justify the “reasonableness” of the suspicion on which the applicants’ detention was supposed to have been based, in the absence either of a specific assessment of the individual items of evidence in the file, or of any information available in the file at the material time that could have justified the suspicion against the applicants, or of any other kinds of verifiable material or facts.

9. The Court further notes that the applicants’ initial pre-trial detention orders were mainly based on information indicating their use of the ByLock messaging system, banking activities considered as financing the FETÖ/PDY, subscriptions to certain pro-FETÖ/PDY publications, having in their possessions United States one‑dollar bills with an “F” serial number, and/or their employment by and/or memberships in FETÖ/PDY-affiliated institutions and organisations. To the extent that the detention orders have taken into account the applicants’ alleged use of the ByLock messaging system, the Court notes that it has already found that the use of ByLock alone was not of a nature to constitute “reasonable suspicion” within the meaning of Article 5 § 1 (c) in respect of the offence attributed to the applicants (see Akgün v. Turkey, no. 19699/18, §§ 151-85, 20 July 2021, and Taner Kılıç v. Turkey (no. 2), no. 208/18, §§ 102-03 and 106-09, 31 May 2022). The Court also notes that as regards some of the applicants, the Government have referred to the existence of witness statements justifying the measures in question. It observes, however, that there are no statements in the case files referring to concrete and specific facts that may have given rise to a reasonable suspicion against the applicants concerned at the material time. The Court further considers, as relevant, that the other acts imputed to the applicants (see paragraph 2 above) were merely circumstantial elements which, in the absence of any other information capable of justifying the suspicions in question, benefited from the presumption of legality and cannot reasonably be regarded as constituting a body of evidence demonstrating the applicants’ membership of a terrorist organisation (compare Taner Kılıç, cited above, §§ 104-05 and the cases cited therein).

10. Since the Government have not provided any other indications, “facts” or “information” capable of satisfying it that the applicants were “reasonably suspected”, at the time of their initial detention, of having committed the alleged offence, the Court finds that the requirements of Article 5 § 1 (c) regarding the “reasonableness” of a suspicion justifying detention have not been satisfied (see Baş, cited above, § 195, and Taner Kılıç, cited above, §§ 114-16). At this juncture, it cannot be maintained, as the Government argued in their observations, that the fact that the applicants were not members of the judiciary had any bearing on the conclusion reached. Moreover, while the Government commented that the applicants in applications nos. 61564/19, 2841/20 and 22465/19 had actively participated in the failed coup attempt or had been arrested while attempting to leave the country, the Court observes that no such findings were made in the initial detention orders with respect to these applicants. It finally considers that while the applicants were detained a short time after the coup attempt – that is, the event that prompted the declaration of the state of emergency and the notice of derogation by Türkiye –, which is undoubtedly a contextual factor that should be fully taken into account in interpreting and applying Article 5 of the Convention in the present case, the measure at issue cannot be said to have been strictly required by the exigencies of the situation (compare Baş, cited above, §§ 115-16 and §§ 196‑201). It therefore concludes that there has been a violation of Article 5 § 1 of the Convention.

OTHER COMPLAINTS

11. As regards any remaining complaints under Article 5 §§ 1, 3, 4 and 5 of the Convention, the Court decides not to examine them, in view of its findings under Article 5 § 1 above and its considerations in the case of Turan and Others (cited above, § 98).

APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION

12. The applicants, except for the applicants in applications nos. 48400/19, 49703/19, 49910/19, 62956/19, 1615/20, 4397/20, 9639/20, 11997/20, 13673/20, 22973/20, 30443/20, 34186/20, 38467/20, 16538/21 and 16895/21, requested compensation in varying amounts in respect of non‑pecuniary damage within the time-limit allotted. Most of the applicants in question also claimed pecuniary damage, as well as the legal costs and expenses incurred before the domestic courts and the Court.

13. The Government contested the applicants’ claims as being unsubstantiated and excessive.

14. For the reasons put forth in Turan and Others (cited above, §§ 102‑07), the Court rejects any claims for pecuniary damage and awards each of the applicants, save for the applicants in applications nos. 48400/19, 49703/19, 49910/19, 62956/19, 1615/20, 4397/20, 9639/20, 11997/20, 13673/20, 22973/20, 30443/20, 34186/20, 38467/20, 16538/21 and 16895/21, a lump sum of 5,000 euros (EUR), covering non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable on that amount.

FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY,

Decides to join the applications;
Declares the complaint under Article 5 § 1 of the Convention, concerning the alleged lack of reasonable suspicion, at the time of the applicants’ initial pre-trial detention, that they had committed an offence, admissible;
Holds that there has been a violation of Article 5 § 1 of the Convention on account of the lack of reasonable suspicion, at the time of the applicants’ initial pre-trial detention, that they had committed an offence;
Holds that there is no need to examine the admissibility and merits of the applicants’ remaining complaints under Article 5 of the Convention;
Holds

(a) that the respondent State is to pay each of the applicants, save for the applicants in applications nos. 48400/19, 49703/19, 49910/19, 62956/19, 1615/20, 4397/20, 9639/20, 11997/20, 13673/20, 22973/20, 30443/20, 34186/20, 38467/20, 16538/21 and 16895/21, within three months, EUR 5,000 (five thousand euros) in respect of non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable on this amount, which is to be converted into the currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable at the date of settlement;

(b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amount at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points;

Dismisses the remainder of the applicants’ claims for just satisfaction.

Done in English, and notified in writing on 25 June 2024, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.

Dorothee von Arnim Pauliine Koskelo
Deputy Registrar President

APPENDIX

List of cases:

No.	Application no.	Case name	Lodged on	Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality	Represented by
1.	58437/17	Duymaz v. Türkiye	12/07/2017	Mehmet DUYMAZ 1981 Ankara Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
2.	58438/17	Dorum v. Türkiye	10/07/2017	İsmail DORUM 1967 Isparta Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
3.	58439/17	Öz v. Türkiye	12/07/2017	Nuri ÖZ 1983 Ankara Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
4.	58452/17	Çipil v. Türkiye	24/07/2017	Yavuz ÇİPİL 1978 Ankara Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
5.	58454/17	Reis v. Türkiye	21/07/2017	Selçuk REİS 1970 Aksaray Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
6.	58456/17	Tekin v. Türkiye	17/07/2017	Hamdi TEKİN 1975 Eskişehir Turkish	Gülhis YÖRÜK
7.	60995/17	Bostan v. Türkiye	31/07/2017	Hasan BOSTAN 1967 Bursa Turkish	Mustafa UYSAL
8.	80976/17	Aksan v. Türkiye	09/11/2017	Hüseyin AKSAN 1986 Ankara Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
9.	82731/17	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	31/10/2017	Hakan YILDIRIM 1987 Ankara Turkish	Gülhis YÖRÜK
10.	82739/17	Keleş v. Türkiye	03/11/2017	Savaş KELEŞ 1978 Ankara Turkish	Gülhis YÖRÜK
11.	20497/18	Üner v. Türkiye	10/04/2018	Mustafa ÜNER 1981 Antalya Turkish	Sultan TEKE SOYDİNÇ
12.	27945/18	Mete v. Türkiye	30/05/2018	Sami METE 1973 Istanbul Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
13.	30186/18	Öztürk v. Türkiye	20/06/2018	Akif ÖZTÜRK 1980 Tokat Turkish	Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU
14.	32959/18	Durdu v. Türkiye	03/07/2018	Raşit DURDU 1979 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
15.	32981/18	Saka v. Türkiye	03/07/2018	Sabri SAKA 1976 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
16.	47192/18	Gülen v. Türkiye	02/10/2018	Pınar GÜLEN 1984 Adana Turkish	Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
17.	15792/19	Gürel v. Türkiye	11/03/2019	Ahmet GÜREL 1966 Tekirdağ Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
18.	16572/19	Uçar v. Türkiye	16/03/2019	Hasan Hüseyin UÇAR 1978 Kocaeli Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
19.	17512/19	Arıtürk v. Türkiye	14/03/2019	Burhan ARITÜRK 1974 Antalya Turkish	Nurcan KAYMAZ ÇEKİÇOĞLU
20.	17576/19	Elma v. Türkiye	01/03/2019	Ahmet ELMA 1973 Tekirdağ Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
21.	19178/19	Atasoy v. Türkiye	28/03/2019	Kenan ATASOY 1978 Ankara Turkish	İbrahim Halil UZUN
22.	19832/19	Türkoğlu v. Türkiye	25/03/2019	Hakan TÜRKOĞLU 1986 Konya Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
23.	22465/19	Tirit v. Türkiye	18/04/2019	Süleyman TİRİT 1965 İzmir Turkish	Özlem SUZAN
24.	22489/19	Kılıç v. Türkiye	16/04/2019	Fatih KILIÇ 1972 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
25.	24839/19	Küççük v. Türkiye	03/05/2019	Mesut KÜÇÇÜK 1989 İstanbul Turkish	Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU
26.	24953/19	Şimşek v. Türkiye	30/04/2019	Mutlu ŞİMŞEK 1974 Eskişehir Turkish	Mustafa ALGAM
27.	25289/19	Gülgen v. Türkiye	22/04/2019	Cumhur GÜLGEN 1971 İzmir Turkish	Serkan CENGİZ
28.	26037/19	Kılıçaslan v. Türkiye	23/04/2019	Fatih KILIÇASLAN 1985 Giresun Turkish	Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU
29.	27196/19	Çetingül v. Türkiye	10/05/2019	Fatih ÇETİNGÜL 1985 Konya Turkish	Nursel AKGÜN
30.	27772/19	Tonga v. Türkiye	10/05/2019	Hasan Basri TONGA 1964 Kırıkkale Turkish	Zafer İRAZ
31.	29535/19	Yaşar v. Türkiye	10/05/2019	Ramazan YAŞAR 1975 Antalya Turkish	Nurcan KAYMAZ ÇEKİÇOĞLU
32.	29756/19	Yoldaş v. Türkiye	24/05/2019	İshak YOLDAŞ 1984 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
33.	30055/19	Kadıoğlu v. Türkiye	31/05/2019	Dursun Ali KADIOĞLU 1980 Rize Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
34.	30057/19	Onat v. Türkiye	17/05/2019	Zeliha Gül ONAT 1972 Manisa Turkish	Ayşe Rabia YÜREKLİTÜRK
35.	30082/19	Yerkazanoğlu v. Türkiye	28/05/2019	Nevin YERKAZANOĞLU 1952 Manisa Turkish	Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
36.	30972/19	Er v. Türkiye	31/05/2019	Mevlüt ER 1975 Tokat Turkish	Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU
37.	32207/19	Zengin v. Türkiye	10/06/2019	Raşit ZENGİN 1973 Manisa Turkish	Nursel AKGÜN
38.	32265/19	Aydın v. Türkiye	03/06/2019	İbrahim AYDIN 1978 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
39.	34245/19	Köksal v. Türkiye	18/06/2019	Bayram KÖKSAL 1977 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
40.	35131/19	Altıntaş v. Türkiye	21/06/2019	Sezgin ALTINTAŞ 1971 Kocaeli Turkish
41.	35260/19	Yüce v. Türkiye	27/06/2019	Ali YÜCE 1991 Ankara Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
42.	35481/19	Ünsal v. Türkiye	06/05/2019	Zafer ÜNSAL 1981 Ankara Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
43.	35989/19	YILDIZ v. Türkiye	21/06/2019	Turgut YILDIZ 1984 Kocaeli Turkish	İbrahim Halil UZUN
44.	36066/19	Apa v. Türkiye	21/06/2019	Salih APA 1983 Denizli Turkish	İbrahim Halil UZUN
45.	36190/19	ErYILMAZ v. Türkiye	21/06/2019	Ali ERYILMAZ 1979 Karabük Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
46.	37100/19	Çetin v. Türkiye	26/06/2019	Ali Rıza ÇETİN 1962 Kocaeli Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
47.	37240/19	Özbey v. Türkiye	20/06/2019	Yusuf ÖZBEY 1984 Ankara Turkish	Necip Fazıl YILDIZ
48.	37253/19	Yanbay v. Türkiye	13/06/2019	Ahmet YANBAY 1971 Bursa Turkish	Ahmet Sami GÜLŞEN
49.	37276/19	Köse v. Türkiye	09/07/2019	İbrahim KÖSE 1975 Osmaniye Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
50.	37619/19	Baş v. Türkiye	04/07/2019	Ali BAŞ 1956 Aydın Turkish	Mustafa AÇICI
51.	38696/19	Polat v. Türkiye	05/07/2019	Abdullah POLAT 1986 Tekirdağ Turkish	Havva NALBANT TEKİN
52.	40185/19	Duman v. Türkiye	17/07/2019	Çetin DUMAN 1975 Istanbul Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
53.	40393/19	Aslan v. Türkiye	19/07/2019	Alper ASLAN 1981 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
54.	40635/19	Turan v. Türkiye	22/07/2019	Bünyamin Cüneyt TURAN 1978 Tekirdağ Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
55.	40692/19	Arıcan v. Türkiye	19/07/2019	Osman Serhat ARICAN 1986 Kırıkkale Turkish	Tuğba ARICAN
56.	40804/19	Bayraktar v. Türkiye	17/07/2019	Nilüfer BAYRAKTAR 1982 Düzce Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
57.	40813/19	Büyükemirusta v. Türkiye	28/07/2019	Hilmi BÜYÜKEMİRUSTA 1973 Denizli Turkish	Tarık AVŞAR
58.	40940/19	Tunahan v. Türkiye	23/07/2019	Tarık TUNAHAN 1973 Ankara Turkish	Muhammed Mustafa GÜRSOY
59.	41212/19	Ertaş v. Türkiye	03/07/2019	Fatih ERTAŞ 1977 Kocaeli Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
60.	41299/19	Gürler v. Türkiye	26/07/2019	Aziz GÜRLER 1976 Burdur Turkish	Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ
61.	41659/19	Acar v. Türkiye	27/06/2019	Ahmet ACAR 1989 Istanbul Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
62.	41699/19	Böken v. Türkiye	16/07/2019	Ali Ahmet BÖKEN 1971 Ankara Turkish	Erşan CANSEVEN
63.	41779/19	Satık v. Türkiye	02/08/2019	Ömer SATIK 1984 Ankara Turkish
64.	42047/19	Dağ v. Türkiye	01/08/2019	İsmail DAĞ 1986 Ankara Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
65.	42089/19	Bülbül v. Türkiye	29/07/2019	Arslan BÜLBÜL 1990 Gaziantep Turkish	Hasan Önder SULU
66.	42156/19	Daşkın v. Türkiye	26/07/2019	Fatih DAŞKIN 1981 Kırşehir Turkish	Elif KATI
67.	42540/19	Türkaydın v. Türkiye	06/08/2019	Kadir TÜRKAYDIN 1984 Çorum Turkish	Ufuk Sami HAKVERDİ
68.	42869/19	Acar v. Türkiye	05/08/2019	Özkan ACAR 1988 Düzce Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
69.	43361/19	Ulun v. Türkiye	06/08/2019	Fatih Sait ULUN 1973 Kırıkkale Turkish	Vasfiye ULUN
70.	43388/19	Onat v. Türkiye	02/08/2019	Hasan Gürhan ONAT 1971 Manisa Turkish	Zafer Asım SERBEST
71.	43407/19	Akarsu v. Türkiye	07/08/2019	Üzeyir AKARSU 1984 Düzce Turkish	Bekir DÖNMEZ
72.	43422/19	Eryaman v. Türkiye	21/07/2019	Metin ERYAMAN 1966 Niğde Turkish	Firdevs ERYAMAN
73.	44990/19	Aktepe v. Türkiye	23/08/2019	Basri AKTEPE 1965 Ankara Turkish	Halil Melih AKTEPE
74.	44993/19	Demirbaş v. Türkiye	23/08/2019	Salim DEMİRBAŞ 1974 Denizli Turkish	Osman TABU
75.	45864/19	Ateş v. Türkiye	29/08/2019	Onur ATEŞ 1984 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
76.	46150/19	Urbay v. Türkiye	31/08/2019	Osman URBAY 1989 Giresun Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
77.	46772/19	ŞAHİN v. Türkiye	26/08/2019	Fatih ŞAHİN 1966 Ankara Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
78.	47943/19	Çelik v. Türkiye	21/08/2019	Zafer ÇELİK 1983 Ankara Turkish	Naim UZUN
79.	48063/19	Moran v. Türkiye	05/09/2019	Rukiye MORAN 1978 Kayseri Turkish	Burak ÇAĞ
80.	48104/19	Bayzan v. Türkiye	11/09/2019	Murat BAYZAN 1978 Denizli Turkish	İsmail KAPLAN
81.	48359/19	Taner v. Türkiye	02/09/2019	Ayşe TANER 1988 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
82.	48400/19	Aksoy v. Türkiye	11/09/2019	Erkan AKSOY 1982 Manisa Turkish	Esra AKSOY
83.	48552/19	Bavik v. Türkiye	20/05/2019	Selahattin BAVİK 1981 Kocaeli Turkish	Elvan BAĞ CANBAZ
84.	49211/19	Karanfil v. Türkiye	29/08/2019	Remzi KARANFİL 1972 Trabzon Turkish	Muhammed Nuh POLAT
85.	49391/19	Körpe v. Türkiye	06/09/2019	Mustafa KÖRPE 1988 Van Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
86.	49408/19	Uzun v. Türkiye	11/09/2019	Abdullah UZUN 1975 Trabzon Turkish	Muhammed Nuh POLAT
87.	49703/19	Gücük v. Türkiye	10/09/2019	Mahmut GÜCÜK 1971 Elazığ Turkish	Gizem GÜZEL
88.	49722/19	Mertkaya v. Türkiye	09/09/2019	Okan MERTKAYA 1979 İzmir Turkish	Bülent ÖNÜR
89.	49910/19	Atabay v. Türkiye	19/09/2019	Ulvi Murat ATABAY 1978 Istanbul Turkish	Serkan BEN
90.	50264/19	Künç v. Türkiye	10/09/2019	Yaşar KÜNÇ 1974 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
91.	50714/19	Bayram v. Türkiye	17/08/2019	Levent BAYRAM 1973 Izmir Turkish	Ülkü BAYRAM
92.	51075/19	Açar v. Türkiye	02/09/2019	Murat AÇAR 1987 Burdur Turkish	Hülya AÇAR
93.	51206/19	Gedikli v. Türkiye	03/09/2019	Abdullah GEDİKLİ 1979 Aydın Turkish	Esra Nur AKYOL
94.	51415/19	Kulaksiz v. Türkiye	23/09/2019	Şenol KULAKSIZ 1972 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
95.	51491/19	Çoban v. Türkiye	27/08/2019	Ahmet ÇOBAN 1988 Amasya Turkish	Tahir EREN
96.	51794/19	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	29/08/2019	Burhan YILDIRIM 1967 Istanbul Turkish	Meryem GÜNAY
97.	52109/19	Elmas v. Türkiye	23/09/2019	Leyla ELMAS 1987 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
98.	53526/19	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	26/09/2019	Mehmet Akif YILDIRIM 1966 Hatay Turkish	Numan YILDIRIM
99.	53571/19	Hancıoğlu v. Türkiye	09/10/2019	Davut HANCIOĞLU 1974 İzmir Turkish	Özlem SUZAN
100.	53673/19	Zincirkıran v. Türkiye	30/09/2019	Mevlüt ZİNCİRKIRAN 1975 Nevşehir Turkish	Ali ÇİTİL
101.	53735/19	Tekin v. Türkiye	26/09/2019	Salih TEKİN 1979 Karaman Turkish	Yunus Emre DOĞAN
102.	54004/19	Doğan v. Türkiye	04/09/2019	Selçuk DOĞAN 1980 Çanakkale Turkish	Samet YILMAZ
103.	54136/19	Osmanoğlu v. Türkiye	30/09/2019	Ayhan OSMANOĞLU 1975 Kocaeli Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
104.	54144/19	Cantaş v. Türkiye	02/10/2019	Cengiz CANTAŞ 1976 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
105.	54800/19	Aksoy v. Türkiye	05/10/2019	Özcan AKSOY 1969 Denizli Turkish	Serhat ŞAHİN
106.	54823/19	Yurdalan v. Türkiye	14/10/2019	Muhammet YURDALAN 1992 Ankara Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
107.	55613/19	Koç v. Türkiye	24/09/2019	Murat KOÇ 1989 Nevsehir Turkish	Bekir DEMİRCİOĞLU
108.	55767/19	Yalın v. Türkiye	04/10/2019	İlhan YALIN 1972 Sakarya Turkish	Zerrin YALIN
109.	56434/19	Erden v. Türkiye	18/10/2019	Süleyman ERDEN 1974 Denizli Turkish	Tarık AVŞAR
110.	56477/19	Kocaman v. Türkiye	15/10/2019	Muharrem KOCAMAN 1985 Düzce Turkish	Ömer Faruk YAZGELDİ
111.	56884/19	Şatıroğlu v. Türkiye	17/10/2019	Samet ŞATIROĞLU 1990 Ankara Turkish	Nurcan BÜYÜKÇINAR
112.	57057/19	Yurtcu v. Türkiye	25/10/2019	Ahmet YURTÇU 1986 Istanbul Turkish	Enes KABADAYI
113.	57349/19	Şekerci v. Türkiye	18/10/2019	Talat ŞEKERCİ 1962 Zonguldak Turkish	Burhan Temel ÇINAR
114.	57465/19	Karalı v. Türkiye	23/10/2019	Ümit KARALI 1992 Istanbul Turkish	İbrahim Alper CAN
115.	57479/19	Küçükbaşol v. Türkiye	22/10/2019	Şuayip KÜÇÜKBAŞOL 1977 Sivas Turkish	Zafer İRAZ
116.	57668/19	Sahin v. Türkiye	15/10/2019	Harun SAHİN 1979 Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
117.	57763/19	Sert v. Türkiye	04/11/2019	Tuncay SERT 1980 Denizli Turkish	Mehmet TUNÇER
118.	58097/19	Tekkoyun v. Türkiye	11/10/2019	Mesut TEKKOYUN 1984 Denizli Turkish	İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
119.	58124/19	İldemir v. Türkiye	30/10/2019	Emre İLDEMİR 1984 Zonguldak Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
120.	59151/19	Solmaz v. Türkiye	08/11/2019	İbrahim SOLMAZ 1974 Kayseri Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
121.	59927/19	Birkin v. Türkiye	06/11/2019	Murat BİRKİN 1974 Kayseri Turkish	Rana BİRKİN
122.	61212/19	Kaplan v. Türkiye	23/11/2019	Muhammed KAPLAN 1991 Pamukkale Turkish	Bekir Gökhan ÖZTÜRK
123.	61247/19	Manas v. Türkiye	20/11/2019	Mustafa MANAS 1984 Denizli Turkish	Tarık AVŞAR
124.	61564/19	Sarı v. Türkiye	20/11/2019	Abdulkadir SARI 1983 Ankara Turkish	Ayşe Süeda ÜNAL
125.	61582/19	Sefil v. Türkiye	11/11/2019	Yusuf SEFİL 1980 Bolu Turkish	Hatice SEFİL
126.	61597/19	Bostan v. Türkiye	13/11/2019	Necati BOSTAN 1970 Elazığ Turkish	Arzu BEYAZİT
127.	61634/19	Özkan v. Türkiye	08/11/2019	Mehmet ÖZKAN 1978 Aydın Turkish	Fatma ÖZKAN
128.	61662/19	Akyürek v. Türkiye	11/11/2019	Mehmet Fatih AKYÜREK 1994 Hatay Turkish	Özgür Devran ÜNEŞİ
129.	61893/19	Çoban v. Türkiye	15/11/2019	Mehmet Şirin ÇOBAN 1982 Konya Turkish	Nilay NAYMAN
130.	62030/19	Dogan v. Türkiye	19/11/2019	Hasan DOĞAN 1976 Kocaeli Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
131.	62378/19	Doğman v. Türkiye	18/11/2019	Ali İhsan DOĞMAN 1972 Ankara Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
132.	62623/19	Dişlen v. Türkiye	18/11/2019	Mustafa DİŞLEN 1984 Osmaniye Turkish	Fatma Zarif TUNÇ
133.	62956/19	Işık v. Türkiye	19/11/2019	Ayhan IŞIK 1985 Kırıkkale Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
134.	63023/19	Ökmen v. Türkiye	14/11/2019	Mustafa ÖKMEN 1968 Manisa Turkish	İrem TATLIDEDE
135.	63516/19	Çelebi v. Türkiye	18/11/2019	Serkan ÇELEBİ 1982 Istanbul Turkish	Cihat ÇITIR
136.	64029/19	Koçtürk v. Türkiye	09/12/2019	Uğur KOÇTÜRK 1975 Konya Turkish	Nursel AKGÜN
137.	64892/19	Dinç v. Türkiye	26/11/2019	İlker DİNÇ 1977 Turkish	Utku Coşkuner SAKARYA
138.	64941/19	Kuğu v. Türkiye	06/12/2019	Bilgin KUĞU 1967 Ankara Turkish	Esad MEMİŞ
139.	65111/19	Topatmış v. Türkiye	03/12/2019	Cengiz TOPATMIŞ 1965 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Adnan ERDOĞAN
140.	65223/19	Senğül v. Türkiye	18/12/2019	Yavuz SENĞÜL 1980 Kırıkkale Turkish	Cemaynur GÜVEN
141.	119/20	Yüksel v. Türkiye	19/12/2019	İsmail YÜKSEL 1978 Eskişehir Turkish	Mustafa ALGAM
142.	125/20	YILMAZ v. Türkiye	19/12/2019	Burak Yasin YILMAZ 1987 Eskişehir Turkish	Mustafa ALGAM
143.	627/20	Ersöz v. Türkiye	23/12/2019	Süleyman ERSÖZ 1985 Bolu Turkish	Sezgin ÖZDEMİR
144.	1156/20	Şen v. Türkiye	17/12/2019	Yavuz ŞEN 1987 Kocaeli Turkish	Çiğdem ŞEN
145.	1265/20	Uzunali v. Türkiye	20/12/2019	Erdinç UZUNALİ 1987 Balıkesir Turkish	Zafer İRAZ
146.	1398/20	Danışman v. Türkiye	27/12/2019	Abdullah Mutlu DANIŞMAN 1982 Bitlis Turkish	Mahir ORAK
147.	1615/20	Ayverdi v. Türkiye	13/12/2019	Ferdi AYVERDİ 1981 Manisa Turkish	Mustafa Safa SOYDAN
148.	2126/20	Şahan v. Türkiye	02/01/2020	Mehmet ŞAHAN 1974 Kocaeli Turkish	Fatma ŞAHAN
149.	2194/20	Demir v. Türkiye	19/12/2019	Vedat DEMİR 1966 Istanbul Turkish	Suphi Uğur ÇÖREKÇİ
150.	2465/20	Özcan v. Türkiye	06/01/2020	Özgür ÖZCAN 1987 Eskişehir Turkish	Ömer Tarık ORMANCI
151.	2523/20	Uysal v. Türkiye	19/12/2019	Erdoğan UYSAL 1973 Düzce Turkish	Ömer Faruk YAZGELDİ
152.	2567/20	Kınık v. Türkiye	26/12/2019	Özden KINIK 1969 Ankara Turkish	Erşan CANSEVEN
153.	2841/20	Altınova v. Türkiye	04/12/2019	Suat ALTINOVA 1976 Düzce Turkish	İsmail CAN
154.	3578/20	Erkart v. Türkiye	30/12/2019	Yusuf ERKART 1975 Eskişehir Turkish	Mustafa ÖZEL
155.	4193/20	Sayılı v. Türkiye	03/01/2020	Hasan SAYILI 1986 Ankara Turkish	Erşan CANSEVEN
156.	4397/20	Sağıroğlu v. Türkiye	31/12/2019	Mustafa SAĞIROĞLU 1985 Kırıkkale Turkish	Halil İbrahim TURAN
157.	4639/20	Elibol v. Türkiye	15/01/2020	Mehmet Emre ELİBOL 1982 Kırşehir Turkish	Kamile ÖZBULUT
158.	4812/20	Gazioğlu v. Türkiye	03/01/2020	Aynur GAZİOĞLU 1991 Gebze Turkish	Fatih DİŞCİ
159.	5030/20	Öztürk v. Türkiye	10/01/2020	Seydi Vakkas ÖZTÜRK 1977 Gaziantep Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
160.	5508/20	Yaman v. Türkiye	20/01/2020	Oğuz YAMAN 1978 Düzce Turkish	Yasemin YAMAN
161.	6082/20	Aytaç v. Türkiye	24/01/2020	Burak AYTAÇ 1991 Balıkesir Turkish	Ahmet Alp AYTAÇ
162.	6278/20	Yücetürk v. Türkiye	21/01/2020	Ramazan YÜCETÜRK 1986 Denizli Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
163.	6830/20	Tıknas v. Türkiye	21/01/2020	Tufan TIKNAS 1982 Kocaeli Turkish	Metehan USLUEROL
164.	6915/20	Akkuş v. Türkiye	21/01/2020	Murat AKKUŞ 1985 Kocaeli Turkish	Metehan USLUEROL
165.	6920/20	Şahan v. Türkiye	16/01/2020	Ferit ŞAHAN 1988 Kocaeli Turkish	Metehan USLUEROL
166.	7134/20	Uçan v. Türkiye	13/01/2020	Engin UÇAN 1977 Balikesir Turkish	Hüseyin UÇAN
167.	7857/20	Safaz v. Türkiye	27/01/2020	İsmail SAFAZ 1972 Kayseri Turkish	Enes Bahadır BAŞKÖY
168.	7900/20	Abidik v. Türkiye	29/01/2020	Adem Ali ABİDİK 1965 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
169.	7903/20	Topoğlu v. Türkiye	03/02/2020	Serhat TOPOĞLU 1977 Ankara Turkish	Refia TAŞCIOĞLU
170.	8082/20	Gündüz v. Türkiye	22/01/2020	Fatih GÜNDÜZ 1988 Ağrı Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
171.	8087/20	Koçer v. Türkiye	22/01/2020	Niyazi KOÇER 1971 Bursa Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
172.	8097/20	Şeker v. Türkiye	29/01/2020	Adem ŞEKER 1981 Kocaeli Turkish	Metehan USLUEROL
173.	9268/20	Oluç v. Türkiye	03/02/2020	Rıdvan OLUÇ 1977 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
174.	9353/20	Uzun v. Türkiye	17/12/2019	Cem UZUN 1977 Ankara Turkish	Utku Coşkuner SAKARYA
175.	9639/20	Altan v. Türkiye	05/02/2020	Bayram ALTAN 1976 Ankara Turkish	Bedirhan Tuna YILDIZ
176.	9986/20	Orta v. Türkiye	18/02/2020	Hüseyin ORTA 1970 Ankara Turkish	Beyhan ORTA
177.	11014/20	Yavaşcan v. Türkiye	17/02/2020	Yusuf YAVAŞCAN 1956 Istanbul Turkish	Handan YAVAŞCAN MARHAN
178.	11221/20	Birişik v. Türkiye	10/02/2020	Muhammed BİRİŞİK 1988 Malatya Turkish	Faik BİRİŞİK
179.	11302/20	Güler v. Türkiye	18/02/2020	Ramazan GÜLER 1987 Istanbul Turkish	Burak ÇAĞ
180.	11476/20	Özdemir v. Türkiye	18/02/2020	Ergün ÖZDEMİR 1975 İzmir Turkish	Hatice ÖZDEMİR
181.	11695/20	Özder v. Türkiye	27/02/2020	İsmail ÖZDER 1983 Manisa Turkish	Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
182.	11997/20	Ak v. Türkiye	18/02/2020	Ayhan AK 1972 Kocaeli Turkish	Ersayın İŞIK
183.	12646/20	Yamaç v. Türkiye	28/02/2020	Mustafa YAMAÇ 1989 Burdur Turkish	Mehmet TUNÇER
184.	12671/20	Gürzal v. Türkiye	21/02/2020	Ergün GÜRZAL 1970 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
185.	12898/20	Özdamar v. Türkiye	04/03/2020	Yusuf Kürşad ÖZDAMAR 1978 Manisa Turkish	Arzu ÖZDAMAR
186.	13112/20	Akyazı v. Türkiye	20/02/2020	Cengiz AKYAZI 1988 Bursa Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
187.	13673/20	İnce v. Türkiye	07/03/2020	Mustafa İNCE 1996 Manisa Turkish	Salim Serdar YAĞCI
188.	13760/20	Tandoğan v. Türkiye	25/02/2020	Nuh TANDOĞAN 1965 Sinop Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
189.	14844/20	Genç v. Türkiye	06/03/2020	Mehmet Zeki GENÇ 1965 Siirt Turkish	Mehmet SATICI
190.	15852/20	Çelik v. Türkiye	16/03/2020	Hasan ÇELİK 1972 Ankara Turkish	Cihat ÇITIR
191.	16207/20	Özdemir v. Türkiye	16/03/2020	Mehmet ÖZDEMİR 1979 Aydın Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
192.	16561/20	Arıcan v. Türkiye	18/03/2020	Ahmet ARICAN 1963 Aksaray Turkish	Muhammet Emin ÇITIR
193.	16933/20	Çakmak v. Türkiye	23/03/2020	Çağrı ÇAKMAK 1988 Tokat Turkish	Mustafa YELBEY
194.	16996/20	Tezcan v. Türkiye	20/03/2020	Abdulgani TEZCAN 1979 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
195.	17040/20	Kaya v. Türkiye	17/03/2020	Ahmet Hamdi KAYA 1964 SEE REP. ADDRESS Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
196.	17065/20	Varol v. Türkiye	03/04/2020	Selim VAROL 1979 İzmir Turkish
197.	17119/20	Akkuş v. Türkiye	20/03/2020	Necati AKKUŞ 1980 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
198.	17120/20	Tezel v. Türkiye	09/04/2020	Aykut TEZEL 1976 Denizli Turkish	Özge KIYAK MUSAN
199.	17122/20	Erşen v. Türkiye	24/03/2020	Mahmut Sami ERŞEN 1988 Kayseri Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
200.	17981/20	Dağdelen v. Türkiye	17/04/2020	Osman DAĞDELEN 1987 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Kamile ÖZBULUT
201.	18184/20	Batıhan v. Türkiye	17/04/2020	Sümerya BATIHAN 1992 Çamardı/Niğde Turkish	Demir ABDULSELAM
202.	20148/20	Kaplan v. Türkiye	13/05/2020	Ahmet KAPLAN 1979 Ankara Turkish	Alperen AKARSLAN
203.	20245/20	Mıhcı v. Türkiye	13/05/2020	Doğan MIHCI 1973 Kayseri Turkish	Erşan CANSEVEN
204.	21059/20	Kaya v. Türkiye	22/05/2020	Turgut KAYA 1979 Kastamonu Turkish	Hamide Nur ALKAÇ
205.	21333/20	Mermer v. Türkiye	11/05/2020	Faruk MERMER 1975 Istanbul Turkish	Can AHMETOĞLU
206.	21417/20	Kaya v. Türkiye	20/05/2020	Murat KAYA 1980 Konya Turkish	Muhammet ERDEN
207.	21743/20	Karaca v. Türkiye	28/05/2020	Ayhan KARACA 1975 Ankara Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
208.	21969/20	Demir v. Türkiye	29/05/2020	Sabri DEMİR 1976 İzmir Turkish	Çiğdem ÇALIŞ ÇAĞAN
209.	22427/20	Kök v. Türkiye	02/06/2020	Mustafa Önder KÖK 1972 Antalya Turkish	Nurcan KAYMAZ ÇEKIÇOĞLU
210.	22973/20	Aymak v. Türkiye	21/05/2020	Bilal AYMAK 1991 Kırıkkale Turkish	Adnan DEMİR
211.	23607/20	Sipahioğlu v. Türkiye	02/06/2020	Rıfat SİPAHİOĞLU 1967 ZONGULDAK Turkish	Ömer Faruk YAZGELDİ
212.	23886/20	Aytekin v. Türkiye	21/05/2020	Mehmet Ertaç AYTEKİN 1983 Istanbul Turkish	Özkan OGURLU
213.	23990/20	Obur v. Türkiye	01/06/2020	Özlem OBUR 1989 İzmir Turkish	Metin BOZKURT
214.	24254/20	Eroğlu v. Türkiye	15/06/2020	Abdurrahman EROĞLU 1986 Ankara Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
215.	24293/20	Yaman v. Türkiye	15/06/2020	Bilal YAMAN 1981 Ankara Turkish	Gülsüm YAMAN
216.	24308/20	Karabiber v. Türkiye	11/06/2020	Fatih KARABİBER 1977 Istanbul Turkish	Serdar ATILGAN
217.	24401/20	Uysal v. Türkiye	01/06/2020	Esma Nur UYSAL 1988 İzmir Turkish	Metin BOZKURT
218.	25270/20	Taşkın v. Türkiye	05/06/2020	Ferhat TAŞKIN 1971 Düzce Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
219.	25463/20	Karanfil v. Türkiye	09/06/2020	Ümmühan KARANFİL 1974 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
220.	26395/20	Eroğlu v. Türkiye	19/06/2020	Eyüp EROĞLU 1983 Düzce Turkish	Ömer Faruk YAZGELDİ
221.	26464/20	Özülkü v. Türkiye	22/06/2020	Abdulkadir ÖZÜLKÜ 1988 Batman Turkish	Mehmet Sefa DUMAN
222.	27189/20	Akyol v. Türkiye	26/06/2020	Abdurrahman AKYOL 1964 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Seçkin KESKİN
223.	27256/20	Güller v. Türkiye	17/06/2020	Mücahit GÜLLER 1986 Balıkesir Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
224.	27742/20	Yilmaz v. Türkiye	22/06/2020	Hüseyin YILMAZ 1979 Düzce Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
225.	28033/20	Baykan v. Türkiye	09/06/2020	Davut BAYKAN 1971 Bursa Turkish	Mesut Enes AKBULUT
226.	28759/20	Korkmaz v. Türkiye	30/06/2020	Ahmet KORKMAZ 1995 Osmaniye Turkish	Burak ÇOLAK
227.	28911/20	Kaçmaz v. Türkiye	01/07/2020	Mesut KAÇMAZ 1974 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Ayşe Süeda ÜNAL
228.	29048/20	Kuzgun v. Türkiye	06/07/2020	Kürşat KUZGUN 1982 Ankara Turkish	Fatma HACIPAŞALIOĞLU
229.	29157/20	Uludağ v. Türkiye	24/06/2020	Mustafa Mücahit ULUDAĞ 1978 Karaman Turkish	İsmet ÇELİK
230.	29181/20	Aydın v. Türkiye	06/07/2020	Özcan AYDIN 1975 Rize Turkish	Ayşe Süeda ÜNAL
231.	30443/20	Alp v. Türkiye	16/07/2020	Sadık Turan ALP 1984 İzmir Turkish	İlker BOZ
232.	30661/20	Aydın v. Türkiye	02/07/2020	Mehmet Sabır AYDIN 1988 Balikesir Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
233.	31330/20	Karabacak v. Türkiye	21/07/2020	Burhan KARABACAK 1977 Ankara Turkish	Şule GÖKMEN
234.	32060/20	Gündar v. Türkiye	27/07/2020	Doğan GÜNDAR 1984 Bursa Turkish	Mustafa YELBEY
235.	33806/20	Tekdemir v. Türkiye	04/08/2020	Çetin TEKDEMİR 1972 Istanbul Turkish	Dilara YILMAZ
236.	34186/20	Özkaya v. Türkiye	22/07/2020	Erdoğan ÖZKAYA 1971 İzmir Turkish	Hande Nur ÖZKAYA
237.	34882/20	Çetin v. Türkiye	06/07/2020	Hüseyin ÇETİN 1981 Kayseri Turkish	Ebru EKİCİ
238.	34892/20	Çetinkaya v. Türkiye	10/08/2020	Mehmet Sait ÇETİNKAYA 1986 Kırıkkale Turkish	Mualla ERCAN
239.	35153/20	Şan v. Türkiye	27/07/2020	Ramazan ŞAN 1992 Antalya Turkish	Sultan TEKE SOYDİNÇ
240.	35431/20	Pilevne v. Türkiye	27/07/2020	Murat PİLEVNE 1977 Antalya Turkish	Sultan TEKE SOYDİNÇ
241.	35513/20	Ceylan v. Türkiye	28/07/2020	Zeki CEYLAN 1970 Yalova Turkish	Kubilay TORUN
242.	35598/20	YILDIZ v. Türkiye	13/08/2020	Vehbi YILDIZ 1952 İzmir Turkish	Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
243.	36489/20	Akkul v. Türkiye	28/07/2020	İbrahim AKKUL 1989 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ
244.	36920/20	Kartalcık v. Türkiye	10/08/2020	Vedat KARTALCIK 1971 Isparta Turkish
245.	37627/20	Arslanoğlu v. Türkiye	26/08/2020	Rafet ARSLANOĞLU 1963 Kahramanmaraş Turkish	Ramazan DANIŞMAN
246.	37810/20	Yörüklü v. Türkiye	18/08/2020	Şaban YÖRÜKLÜ 1960 Denizli Turkish	Ali YILDIZ
247.	38208/20	Akduman v. Türkiye	28/08/2020	Mehmet AKDUMAN 1978 Ankara Turkish	Refia TAŞCIOĞLU
248.	38467/20	Yağcı v. Türkiye	27/08/2020	Gülşen YAĞCI 1966 İzmir Turkish	Salim Serdar YAĞCI
249.	38471/20	Karınca v. Türkiye	20/08/2020	Habibe KARINCA 1978 Antalya Turkish	İshak IŞIK
250.	40647/20	Cirakoglu v. Türkiye	02/09/2020	Mehmet ÇIRAKOĞLU 1991 Ankara Turkish	Fatma HACIPAŞALIOĞLU
251.	41368/20	Arlı v. Türkiye	10/09/2020	Seyfettin ARLI 1971 Turkish	Refia TAŞICOĞLU ERBİROL
252.	41470/20	Başpınar v. Türkiye	10/09/2020	İsmail BAŞPINAR 1980 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Refia TAŞCIOĞLU
253.	42543/20	Kara v. Türkiye	15/09/2020	Nevzat KARA 1977 Samsun Turkish	Mehmet TURANTAYLAK
254.	43464/20	Aydın v. Türkiye	19/09/2020	Ünal AYDIN 1982 Yozgat Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
255.	43656/20	Koç v. Türkiye	24/09/2020	Akif KOÇ 1982 Kiriklareli Turkish	Esra KOÇ
256.	45338/20	Ermişoğlu v. Türkiye	09/10/2020	Ergun ERMİŞOĞLU 1980 SEE REP. ADDRESS Turkish	Janset ATİLA
257.	46221/20	Aytaş v. Türkiye	01/10/2020	Kaya Mehmet AYTAŞ 1971 Samsun Turkish	Zeliha DERVIŞOĞLU
258.	46389/20	Karaduman v. Türkiye	08/10/2020	Mustafa KARADUMAN 1985 Kocaeli Turkish	Metehan USLUEROL
259.	46415/20	Kahyaoğlu v. Türkiye	15/10/2020	Hasan KAHYAOĞLU 1963 Denizli Turkish	Cevat KAHYAOĞLU
260.	47619/20	Bozkurt v. Türkiye	22/10/2020	Hasan BOZKURT 1983 Zonguldak Turkish	Beyza Esma TUNA
261.	49561/20	Dalman v. Türkiye	27/10/2020	Cem DALMAN 1983 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Metin BOZKURT
262.	49848/20	Azgın v. Türkiye	04/11/2020	Mehmet AZGIN 1983 Düzce Turkish	Hasan ARSLAN
263.	51357/20	Demirhan v. Türkiye	02/11/2020	Melek DEMİRHAN 1993 Istanbul Turkish	Emriye Zerrin TORAMAN
264.	52833/20	Demircan v. Türkiye	19/11/2020	Hamza DEMİRCAN 1984 Samsun Turkish	Kadir ÖZTÜRK
265.	54974/20	Aksoy v. Türkiye	20/11/2020	Kadir AKSOY 1988 Kırşehir Turkish	Zafer İRAZ
266.	274/21	Kocatürk v. Türkiye	15/12/2020	Kerim KOCATÜRK 1989 Kayseri Turkish	Nesibe Betül KOCATÜRK
267.	544/21	Halıcıoğlu v. Türkiye	14/12/2020	Mevlüt HALICIOĞLU 1985 Turkish	Rümeysa DENİZ
268.	1121/21	Dinc v. Türkiye	09/12/2020	Yakup DİNÇ 1985 Eskişehir Turkish	Elvan BAĞ CANBAZ
269.	1614/21	Karataş v. Türkiye	24/12/2020	Emre KARATAŞ 1994 Istanbul Turkish	Arife ÖZBEK
270.	2100/21	Ayhan v. Türkiye	16/12/2020	Sabri AYHAN 1984 Muğla Turkish	Enes Malik KILIÇ
271.	2314/21	Uzbaş v. Türkiye	29/12/2020	Ali UZBAŞ 1970 Balıkesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
272.	2522/21	Çiftdoğan v. Türkiye	09/12/2020	Yakup ÇİFTDOĞAN 1980 Ankara Turkish	Kamile ÖZBULUT
273.	3085/21	ŞAHİN v. Türkiye	28/12/2020	Akif ŞAHİN 1993 Çorum Turkish	Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
274.	3105/21	Yiğit v. Türkiye	15/12/2020	Ali Galip YİĞİT 1973 Ankara Turkish	Kamile ÖZBULUT
275.	4215/21	Keten v. Türkiye	08/01/2021	Yusuf KETEN 1989 Ankara Turkish	Ayşe Süeda ÜNAL
276.	6525/21	Dombaycı v. Türkiye	20/01/2021	Fatma DOMBAYCI 1982 Denizli Turkish	Tarık AVŞAR
277.	9401/21	Çalık v. Türkiye	28/01/2021	Muhammet Duran ÇALIK 1992 Konya Turkish	Rukiye COŞGUN
278.	10202/21	Samur v. Türkiye	04/01/2021	Aycan SAMUR 1984 Kırıkkale Turkish	İbrahim Halil UZUN
279.	10561/21	Kenger v. Türkiye	03/02/2021	Bekir KENGER 1974 Antalya Turkish	Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
280.	11766/21	Usun v. Türkiye	16/02/2021	Yunus USUN 1987 Sakarya Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
281.	12512/21	Demirci v. Türkiye	11/12/2020	Abdurrahman DEMİRCİ 1982 Ankara Turkish	Rümeysa DENİZ
282.	12612/21	Bayrak v. Türkiye	22/01/2021	Osman BAYRAK 1986 Denizli Turkish	Tarık AVŞAR
283.	14364/21	Özcan v. Türkiye	12/03/2021	Erhan ÖZCAN 1964 Ankara Turkish	Uğur ALTUN
284.	14385/21	Tulukçu v. Türkiye	10/03/2021	Fatma Rumeysa TULUKÇU 1994 Konya Turkish	Refia TAŞCIOĞLU
285.	14430/21	Balcı v. Türkiye	05/03/2021	Sezer BALCI 1982 Tokat Turkish	Zafer İRAZ
286.	15056/21	Bayram v. Türkiye	11/03/2021	Aşir BAYRAM 1971 Afyonkarahisar Turkish	Eyyüp SAĞIR
287.	15557/21	Efel v. Türkiye	11/03/2021	Dudu EFEL 1993 Konya Turkish	Rümeysa DENİZ
288.	16538/21	Soyoral v. Türkiye	05/03/2021	Lokman SOYORAL 1972 Van Turkish	ŞAHİN CANGÜLEÇ
289.	16706/21	Bingül v. Türkiye	11/03/2021	Aysel BİNGÜL 1990 Ankara Turkish	Kamile ÖZBULUT
290.	16895/21	Özlem v. Türkiye	04/03/2021	Sezen ÖZLEM 1975 Edirne Turkish	Yavuzhan VAROL
291.	17102/21	İper v. Türkiye	12/03/2021	Yusuf Emre İPER 1975 Istanbul Turkish	Tora PEKİN
292.	17425/21	Öztürk v. Türkiye	19/03/2021	Mahmut ÖZTÜRK 1974 Konya Turkish	Cihat ÇITIR
293.	17499/21	Esen v. Türkiye	29/03/2021	Ercan ESEN 1970 Balıkesir Turkish	Janset ATİLA
294.	17592/21	Akgül v. Türkiye	23/03/2021	Adem AKGÜL 1978 Antalya Turkish	Nurcan KAYMAZ ÇEKİÇOĞLU
295.	17595/21	Özdemir v. Türkiye	17/03/2021	Muhammet ÖZDEMİR 1989 Gümüşhane Turkish	Mehmet EKİNOĞLU
296.	17840/21	Çitekçi v. Türkiye	23/03/2021	Mehmet ÇİTEKÇİ 1988 Antalya Turkish	Sultan TEKE SOYDİNÇ
297.	20509/21	Taşkent v. Türkiye	14/04/2021	Nurcan TAŞKENT 1979 İstanbul Turkish	Mehmet Sıddık YURTÇİÇEK
298.	22343/21	Erdem v. Türkiye	21/04/2021	Mürsel ERDEM 1976 Izmir Turkish	Kadriye Nur AYTAÇ
299.	22347/21	Erçıkdı v. Türkiye	20/04/2021	Erdal ERÇIKDI 1970 Denizli Turkish	Mehmet TUNÇER
300.	22925/21	Talaz v. Türkiye	29/04/2021	Hüseyin TALAZ 1983 Balikesir Turkish	Burcu HAS
301.	26910/21	Yıldırım v. Türkiye	17/05/2021	Mahmut Şerif YILDIRIM 1988 Uşak Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
302.	27111/21	Düzenli v. Türkiye	10/05/2021	Halim DÜZENLİ 1988 Manisa Turkish	Merve AVCI
303.	28991/21	Hayla v. Türkiye	24/05/2021	Hidaye HAYLA 1984 Denizli Turkish	İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
304.	30423/21	Birinci v. Türkiye	08/06/2021	Erdoğan BİRİNCİ 1982 Giresun Turkish	Erol GÜNAYDIN
305.	30663/21	Şeker v. Türkiye	08/06/2021	Musa ŞEKER 1981 Kırıkkale Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
306.	30926/21	Tiryaki v. Türkiye	20/05/2021	Yunus TİRYAKİ 1990 Ankara Turkish	Fatih DÖNMEZ
307.	31151/21	Özdoğan v. Türkiye	04/06/2021	Ahmet ÖZDOĞAN 1989 Bolu Turkish	Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
308.	33165/21	Eker v. Türkiye	04/06/2021	Turan EKER 1974 Bolu Turkish	İrem GÜNEŞ (DANACIOĞLU)
309.	33343/21	Serter Özlü v. Türkiye	10/06/2021	Zeynep Sacide SERTER ÖZLÜ 1991 Ankara Turkish	Maide ÖZLÜ
310.	34556/21	Aslan v. Türkiye	25/06/2021	Sefer ASLAN 1984 Kırşehir Turkish	Seçkin KESKİN
311.	35695/21	Aslan v. Türkiye	28/06/2021	Hanife Rumeysa ASLAN 1999 Trabzon Turkish	Zümrüt ŞAHİN
312.	39634/21	Koçyiğit v. Türkiye	12/07/2021	Mustafa KOÇYİĞİT 1979 Kırıkkale Turkish	Senem DOĞANOĞLU
313.	42984/21	Ünal v. Türkiye	20/08/2021	Kazım ÜNAL 1980 İzmir Turkish	Kadri İNCE
314.	48723/21	İpkin v. Türkiye	10/09/2021	Gökhan İPKİN 1983 Kayseri Turkish	Erşan CANSEVEN